India Today Group
Surfers' comments
The threshold limits on tax need to be increased and tax rates should be spread across more slabs so as not to hurt the salaried class. - Jayaraman

The I-T exemption for men should be Rs 1.8 lakh. Rs 1.5 lakh is peanuts. - Naveen Kumar
More »
Expert comments
Gaurav Taneja,
Partner & National Tax Director says the Finance Minister has stressed on buoyancy in tax collections and on attaining a Tax—GDP ratio of 12.5%.
Motilal Oswal, Chairman and Managing Director of Motilal Oswal Financial Services says the Finance Minister was uniquely positioned to present a landmark Budget.
Srinivasa Rao, Partner & India International Tax Leader, Ernst & Young is of the opinion that Union Budget has lived up to the populist trend.
Calculators
How this budget affects your
daily life:
Risk Calculator
Future Needs Calculator
Tax Calculator
SIP Calculator
Union Budget 2008-09  »   Story
The campaign begins
Shalini S. Dagar
  Print   Email   A  A  A
 

Not really an agri-push

The key highlight of the Budget is the Rs 60,000 crore splurge on the farm sector in loan waivers for small and marginal farmers up to Rs 50,000 crore and a one-time settlement for other farmers up to Rs 10,000 crore.

That may well be the most visible and election friendly manner of doling out largesse. It is, however, not the most economically feasible manner of lending support to a sector which requires serious investment and tough policy measures to make such investment feasible.

"Loan waivers are neither good economics nor good politics. Most of the small and marginal farmers do not have access to credit at all. Through these waivers we again brand farmers as non-credit worthy," says Amir Ullah Khan, Director, India Development Foundation. "Again we misunderstand the problem of the Indian farmer. They do not give the farmers roads, power or anything of consequence."

In fact, Khan believes a better mechanism would have been to provide a direct subsidy of, say, Rs 15,000 to every small farmer which would have at least put some money in their hands.

Siddhartha Roy, Economic Advisor to the Tata Group, concurs: "It is important to figure out who will benefit from the waiver measure. It would be better had the Budget focussed more on income-generating measures for small and marginal farmers inside as well as outside agriculture. Budget is somewhat silent on non-farm employment in rural and backward areas as well as the SEZs."

In fact, the mechanism of the loan waiver has not been spelt out in the Budget documents. And this determined implementation of the scheme by June 30, 2008 seems more like preparation for election rather than an effort to boost agriculture.

Though happy with the measures, M.S. Swaminathan, Chairman of Chennai-based M.S. Swaminathan Research Foundation, says: "While the Budget provides relief to those who have borrowed from institutional lenders, mechanisms have to be devised for those left out."

Rana Kapoor, MD and CEO of YES Bank, too, is sanguine about the waiver but concedes, "the waiver of farm loans is a short-term strategy without seriously addressing structural issues." However, what has been disappointing is the lack of long-term goal setting for the sector, which urgently needs sustained investment.

Addressing structural issues, mainly supply side constraints in agriculture, is, however, crucial to tame what is the next big problem for the economy—inflation. Rising prices of primary food articles, which constitute a large part of the inflation basket, is expected to put severe pressure on the economy in the months ahead.

In the last two years alone, world prices of crude oil, commodities and food grains have risen sharply. The international prices of commodities such as wheat more than doubled in this period. In the case of rice the increase has been a sharp 55 per cent. And the Reserve Bank of India and the Economic Advisory Council both concur that it will be a tough year ahead on inflation.

"The management of supply side would remain a crucial task. Food availability would emerge as the biggest challenge over the next 10-12 months. So, we need to go in for strategic grain management practices," says V.Shunmugam, Chief Economist, MCX.

High interest rates add to the problem. Putting pressure on interest rates adversely affects both savings and investment. In such a scenario, increasing government expenditure will only put pressure on inflation. And high inflation always hurts the poor, thus affecting the constituency that the Budget attempts to please.

1 2 3 4 5
Sector Analysis
AUTO
Negotiating a rough patch
Demand growth is expected to be buoyant driven by new vehicle launches, likely softening of interest rates and continued growth on the export front.
More »
Railway Budget
Lalu presents people's budget, slashes fares
The minister announced launch of several new trains and reduction in fares across all classes amid chaos by Opposition in Parliament.
More »
Features
A budget for Bharat
Buoyant tax revenues a lower fiscal deficit and an economy that's in top gear permit the FM to pump big money into agriculture and the social sector. Those efforts might help at the hustings, too.
More »
Economic Survey
'Expand telecom infrastructure, R&D'
"With rapid growth of telecom network, there is a need to further expand the infrastructure and research and development," the survey said.
More »
Surfers' comments
This is a very good budget, especially for agriculture and education. P Chidambaram is the best.
- By Saravanan P (plsharavanan@rediffmail.com)
If you can waive Rs 50,000 crore for farmers what about the tax on housing loan interest? That should also have been reduced.
- Chandra Shekar V (rilshekar@yahoo.co.in)
Please tax the street hawkers and give relief to the salaried persons.
- Rajaram (rajaramghurup@rediffmail.com)
This is the worst budget the finance minister has ever presented. The backbone of the country's economy is the transport but he completely missed it out.
- Jayakaanthan A (jayakaanthan@gmail.com)
The budget is sure to augment growth and will also lessen the volatility of the stock markets.
- Sidharth Paul (sidharth.paul@gmail.com)
Overall, the budget is satisfactory but the health sector should have been given greater importance.
- Ankit Chaudhary (chaudharyankit1987@gmail.com)
More »
Send your feedback
Name
E mail
Business Today's Budget edition
Editorial: Predictably populist budget
Special: Something for everyone...
Column: All for the common man
Exclusive interview with the FM
Maintaining the growth story
The Finance Minister defends Budget 2008 and the Rs 60,000 crore loan waiver doled out to farmers in an exclusive interview to Business Today's Sanjoy Narayan and R Sridharan.
VOX CEOs
"Total reduction of excise duties by 2% will give a welcome boost to the manufacturing sector. Also, the exemption of specified parts of set-top boxes from customs duties is commendable".
- Rakesh Bharti Mittal, Vice Chairman, Bharti Enterprises
More »
Advertisement
Beginner’s guide to budget
Union Budget is an estimate of the Government of India's revenue and expenditure for the end of a particular fiscal year, which usually runs from April 1 to March 31. Read on...
More »
Poll
Are you satisfied with Chidambaram's budget proposals for 2008-09?
Yes
No
Can't Say