India Today Group
Surfers' comments
The threshold limits on tax need to be increased and tax rates should be spread across more slabs so as not to hurt the salaried class. - Jayaraman

The I-T exemption for men should be Rs 1.8 lakh. Rs 1.5 lakh is peanuts. - Naveen Kumar
More »
Expert comments
Gaurav Taneja,
Partner & National Tax Director says the Finance Minister has stressed on buoyancy in tax collections and on attaining a Tax—GDP ratio of 12.5%.
Motilal Oswal, Chairman and Managing Director of Motilal Oswal Financial Services says the Finance Minister was uniquely positioned to present a landmark Budget.
Srinivasa Rao, Partner & India International Tax Leader, Ernst & Young is of the opinion that Union Budget has lived up to the populist trend.
How this budget affects your
daily life:
Risk Calculator
Future Needs Calculator
Tax Calculator
SIP Calculator
Union Budget 2008-09  »   Story
International tax: Towards a new direct tax code
Srinivasa Rao
  Print   Email   A  A  A

The pre-election union Budget was expected to be on populist lines and the current Budget lived up to this trend. The Budget focussed on social outlay and tax reform was not the main driver.

While a recessionary threat exists over the global economic landscape, the Indian economy itself has stayed strong and buoyant over the last year. In these relatively prosperous circumstances, and given that this Budget is the government’s final full-year Budget before the next elections, some trace of populism was almost inevitable.

On the direct tax side, given the buoyancy in revenues, there were expectations that the education cess and surcharge embedded in the effective income-tax rate would be partially or cumulatively removed. The Finance Minister did not oblige and quite unexpectedly, the tax rate on shortterm capital gains has been increased to 15 per cent from the existing rate of 10 per cent. The proposal to offer credit to underlying dividend distribution tax in a two-tier parent/ subsidiary corporate structure is a welcome move, though the fine print does not seem to have been worded as benevolently as the concept itself.

However, several pre-Budget recommendations did not find a place in the Budget. The depreciating dollar against the rupee has been a matter of concern. A number of players in the software industry had proposed extension of the tax holiday benefits. There were also proposals to introduce the mechanism of Advance Pricing Arrangements given the aggressive approach adopted by the Indian tax authorities in the ongoing audits and for those concluded for the last year. This would have provided certainty around the pricing of cross-border, intercompany transactions. Another issue that multinationals have been grappling with relates to permanent establishment (PE) and income attribution. In a few of the recent cases, the tax tribunals have adopted an ad hoc approach to determine the level of income attributable to multinationals where there has been a PE determined.

It would have been in the interest of all if there was a separate deciding authority with international tax expertise to decide on such matters.

The use of companies incorporated in favourable tax jurisdictions to mitigate India capital gains tax, popular with MNC investors, has been a contentious matter in India. There has been speculation that the government may consider introducing anti-abuse provisions in the domestic tax law to mitigate Tax Treaty abuse and to override earlier court decisions on the subject.

The Budget did not contain any clarifications on the taxation of such transactions. The Finance Minister also did not comment on the much-publicised direct tax code, which is expected to be circulated later this year. It is possible that some of these proposals will find a place in the new code.

The UPA government over the last few years has been able to balance development and build a platform for inclusive growth. To conclude, while the corporate sector may have hoped for more from the current Budget, the social schemes of the UPA government will have long-term benefits for the Indian economy provided these are efficiently implemented.

(Srinivasa Rao is Partner & India International Tax Leader, Ernst & Young)

Source: India Today

Sector Analysis
Negotiating a rough patch
Demand growth is expected to be buoyant driven by new vehicle launches, likely softening of interest rates and continued growth on the export front.
More »
Railway Budget
Lalu presents people's budget, slashes fares
The minister announced launch of several new trains and reduction in fares across all classes amid chaos by Opposition in Parliament.
More »
A budget for Bharat
Buoyant tax revenues a lower fiscal deficit and an economy that's in top gear permit the FM to pump big money into agriculture and the social sector. Those efforts might help at the hustings, too.
More »
Economic Survey
'Expand telecom infrastructure, R&D'
"With rapid growth of telecom network, there is a need to further expand the infrastructure and research and development," the survey said.
More »
Surfers' comments
This is a very good budget, especially for agriculture and education. P Chidambaram is the best.
- By Saravanan P (
If you can waive Rs 50,000 crore for farmers what about the tax on housing loan interest? That should also have been reduced.
- Chandra Shekar V (
Please tax the street hawkers and give relief to the salaried persons.
- Rajaram (
This is the worst budget the finance minister has ever presented. The backbone of the country's economy is the transport but he completely missed it out.
- Jayakaanthan A (
The budget is sure to augment growth and will also lessen the volatility of the stock markets.
- Sidharth Paul (
Overall, the budget is satisfactory but the health sector should have been given greater importance.
- Ankit Chaudhary (
More »
Send your feedback
E mail
Business Today's Budget edition
Editorial: Predictably populist budget
Special: Something for everyone...
Column: All for the common man
Exclusive interview with the FM
Maintaining the growth story
The Finance Minister defends Budget 2008 and the Rs 60,000 crore loan waiver doled out to farmers in an exclusive interview to Business Today's Sanjoy Narayan and R Sridharan.
"Total reduction of excise duties by 2% will give a welcome boost to the manufacturing sector. Also, the exemption of specified parts of set-top boxes from customs duties is commendable".
- Rakesh Bharti Mittal, Vice Chairman, Bharti Enterprises
More »
Beginner’s guide to budget
Union Budget is an estimate of the Government of India's revenue and expenditure for the end of a particular fiscal year, which usually runs from April 1 to March 31. Read on...
More »
Are you satisfied with Chidambaram's budget proposals for 2008-09?
Can't Say